Photo of books on a shelf; Photo by Alan Clanton for Thursday Review

Photo by Thursday Review

Court Orders WeLib to Pay For Pirated Books


| published November 16, 2026 |



By Thursday Review staff



A judge in New York City has ordered the pirate website WeLib to pay roughly $19.5 million in damages to various publishers for the theft of millions of books over a several year period.

The same judge also requested those companies and firms which have provided webhosting, domain registrations, and online maintenance for WeLib to shut down the organization’s online operations immediately. The owners and operators of the website—which has been pirating books, newspaper articles, research papers and other copyrighted material for years—failed to respond to the lawsuits brought against them by the publishers whose materials had been stolen.

The ruling against WeLib produced the same dollar figure established only a few months earlier in a nearly identical lawsuit against the book pirating firm Anna’s Archive, which was also ordered to pay $19.5 million.

Both Anna’s Archive and WeLib have been connected—directly and indirectly—the to the much larger litigation moving through the courts regarding major tech companies (Open AI, Microsoft, Anthropic, Gemini, etc) use of pirate websites to harvest books, apparently by the millions, for use in training their Artificial Intelligence mechanisms. Investigators found that after some initial communication back and forth, both Anna’s Archive and WeLib agreed to allow several large tech firms access to the entire library of pirated books—a charge that the large tech firms have not denied.

Both WeLib and Anna’s Archives marketed their services as basically a free library with open access to all books under their roof, inviting those who signed-up to take any materials for “free,” in reality most customers were asked to either make a donation or to pay a monthly subscription fee. Many of the books listed in WeLib’s library had a long waiting list, but customers could pay an additional fee to skip to the top of the waiting list.

Publishers and authors contend that WeLib and Anna’s Archives were simply stealing books and other copyrighted material, then offering to sell it at a large discount. At one time, WeLib had as many as 80,000 users in any given month. Many of these users paid from as little as $7 to as much as $100 for access to the stolen books and articles.

As with the Anna’s Archive lawsuit, even companies which provide web hosting and internet service to WeLib must disable access to the website and transfer the domains to the appropriate publishers.

By the time the WeLib case had made it into the federal courtroom, some dozen or more publishers across a wide array of specialties had joined the case, including publishers of educational, scientific and trade journals, as well as traditional publishers such as HarperCollins, Macmillan, MacGraw-Hill, and Penguin Random House.

Back in May, a judge ruled against Anna’s Archive along the same lines. At least a dozen publishers had joined in that lawsuit, which contended that Anna’s Archive was engaged in theft when it offered the contents of millions of books for “free” to its customers. As in the WeLib case, Anna’s Archive was ordered to shut down.



Related Thursday Review articles:

Suspected AI Use in Novel Scraps $2 Million Book Deal; By R. Alan Clanton, Thursday Review staff; August 22, 2026.

AI Safety Has Moved Beyond the Chatbot Era; By Gleb Tsipursky, Thursday Review contributor; September 14, 2026.